San Francisco’s trajectory has been pointing straight up since Day 1, when they upset the then-Super Bowl favorite LA Rams in Melbourne in the league opener. Before that game, the 49ers were trading at just 5% on Kalshi. Immediately after the win, I wrote about how surprisingly muted the market reaction was. Before hitting publish, I bought in at 7%. Now they're 17%. And I’m cashing out. Here's Why...
The injury bug is already biting. My original thesis relied on the 49ers staying healthy: They made a Divisional Round run last year with essentially their B-team, and if healthy, this team is absolutely a Super Bowl contender. But right now, they are anything but:
Cornerback Deommodore Lenoir is playing through a foot injury, and cornerback Renardo Green is dealing with a bad back. Mike Evans is perpetually banged up (Achilles/rib), Deebo Samuel is clearly hampered, and Trent Williams is nursing a shoulder injury suffered in practice. Nick Bosa is dealing with wear and tear of his own.
And t’s only Week 11. This roster is aging, and the wheels are already starting to wobble. We’ve seen this movie before. Considering San Francisco's track record with injuries, the odds of them surviving the stretch run intact look grim. Even 49ers fans seemed to sense it; when the team became Super Bowl favorites last month, the consensus reaction was "we're peaking too soon..."
Even at full strength, this team isn't as bulletproof as the market is giving them credit for. NBC analyst Chris Simms broke down their glaring weakness this morning. Chris knows football—and, he knows this team as good as anyone. Head coach Kyle Shanahan is, after all, his best friend.
"I don't think they're great in the secondary—in the pass game—and they can't rush the passer with the front four... When they rushed four yesterday ... Prescott just sat back there and he threw it wherever he wanted ... And if you're willing to throw the ball outside the numbers ... you can get the 49ers there, and I think teams will wake up to that..."
Enter the Vikings. This brings us to Sunday night. The Minnesota Vikings are 3-point underdogs against San Francisco on a neutral field in Mexico City. Minnesota is surging on Kalshi, doubling from 4% to 8% since acquiring Kirk Cousins. That the Vikings have the best defense in the NFL is no debate—and now, they finally have a quarterback to match it. Sunday night is already being billed as the "Game of the Year," and I agree. It’s a coin-flip matchup, and the 49ers could easily walk away with a loss here.
The question is, If the 49ers do lose, how will the market react? Answer: The market will cool on San Francisco fast. Looking ahead, they still have two brutal divisional matchups against the Seahawks and Rams, plus a Week 18 showdown against another NFC heavyweight, the Chicago Bears. Meanwhile, a win on Sunday could send Minnesota's momentum into overdrive, vaulting them into the NFC favorite spot by next week.
Of course, the 49ers could still weather the storm, lock up the No. 1 seed, and hold onto their status as market favorites. Could being the key word. The reality is that the NFC is wide open right now. Rather than riding it out with an aging, banged-up roster (and an overrated defense), I’m locking in a ~140% profit and selling high on San Francisco.
As for whether it’s time to buy "low" on the Vikings? I’ll save that for my next piece...